Two new houses refused on Green Belt land in Hersham

  • Elmbridge Borough Council has refused permission for two detached houses at Aurora, Esher Road, Hersham.
  • The primary reason for refusal is that the development constitutes inappropriate Green Belt development, with no very special circumstances demonstrated to outweigh the harm.
  • The council also cited concerns about the design and massing of the proposed houses being out of character with the area.
  • Flood risk, insufficient arboricultural information, and inadequate highway safety details each formed separate grounds for refusal.
  • The decision was issued on 30 October 2026; the applicant has the right of appeal to the Planning Inspectorate.

Elmbridge Borough Council has refused permission for two detached houses on Green Belt land at Aurora, Esher Road, Hersham, citing five separate planning objections including harm to the Green Belt, flood risk, and inadequate highway information.

The application, submitted on behalf of the landowner by agents Carter Jonas, proposed the two dwellings alongside an internal access road, car and cycle parking, and a landscaping scheme, with access taken from Esher Road.

The council's primary reason for refusal was that the development constitutes inappropriate development in the Green Belt, for which no very special circumstances were demonstrated that would clearly outweigh the harm caused. Officers concluded the proposal would have a greater impact on the openness of the Green Belt, contrary to local and national planning policy.

A second ground of refusal held that the layout, design, scale and massing of the proposed houses would appear out of character and overly prominent, causing detrimental harm to the character of the area and the street scene.

The council also refused on flood risk grounds, noting that the site sits in close proximity to existing flood defences and that the submitted flood risk assessment lacked sufficient construction and design detail to demonstrate the development would not increase flood risk elsewhere or be unsafe from flooding.

Insufficient arboricultural information formed a fourth reason, with the council finding the application had not clearly demonstrated that the proposal would avoid a material impact on trees within and adjacent to the site.

Finally, officers found the submitted plans and information too sparse to demonstrate the development would not have a material impact on highway safety and access for future occupiers.

The decision was issued on 30 October 2026.